Current:Home > InvestSupreme Court seems inclined to leave major off-shore tax in place on investors -FutureProof Finance
Supreme Court seems inclined to leave major off-shore tax in place on investors
View
Date:2025-04-18 18:28:44
At the Supreme Court Tuesday, the justices approached a major tax case with all the concern that might have greeted an unexpected ticking package on the front porch. The justices' apprehension is likely justified because their eventual decision in the case could severely limit congressional options in enacting tax policy, and it could cost the federal government trillions of dollars in corporate taxes.
The case before the court is widely seen as a preventive strike against Sen. Elizabeth Warren's wealth tax--not that her proposal has any real chance of being enacted.
But the tax under the judicial microscope Tuesday was enacted in 2017 in part to fund President Trump's massive corporate tax cut. Called the Mandatory Repatriation Tax, or MRT, it imposed a one-time tax on off-shore investment income.
For Charles and Kathleen Moore, that meant they owed a one-time tax of $15,000 on a investment in India--an investment that grew in value from $40,000 to more than $500,000. The Moores paid the tax and then challenged it in court, contending that the tax violates the Sixteenth Amendment to the Constitution, which authorizes Congress to impose taxes on income.
What the federal government can tax
In the Supreme Court chamber Tuesday, the Moores' lawyer, Andrew Grossman, told the court that the federal government can only tax income that is actually paid to the taxpayer—what he called "realized income," as opposed to the Moores' "unrealized income."
Chief Justice John Roberts noted that the corporation in which the Moores invested certainly has realized income. And Justice Sonia Sotomayor asked about the many other ways that investments are taxed, even though there is no pay-out to individuals. These include everything from real estate partnerships to law firms.
"Why do we permit taxing of individual partners" even though "a partner doesn't have personal ownership, doesn't get the value of the partnership, yet we've permitted that tax?"
Grossman replied that "a partnership is a fundamentally different form of organization than a corporation."
Justice Elena Kagan pointed to the country's long history of taxing American shareholders' on their gains from foreign corporations.
"There is quite the history in this country of Congress taxing American shareholders on their gains from foreign corporations and you can see why, right?" Kagan asked. "Congress, the U.S. Government can't tax those foreign corporations directly, and they wanted to make sure that Americans didn't... stash their money in the foreign corporations, watch their money grow, and never pay taxes on them."
And Justice Brett Kavanaugh chimed in with this observation: "We've long held that Congress may attribute the income of the company to the shareholders or the partnership to the partners."
The government's position
Defending the tax, Solicitor General Elizabeth Prelogar faced a grilling from both Justices Samuel Alito and Neil Gorsuch.
"I'm just asking what the limits of your argument are?" said Gorsuch, adding, "It seems to me there are none."
Prelogar replied that under the Constitution, "Congress has broad taxing power." Indeed, she pointed to the Supreme Court's own decisions saying that "Congress has plenary power. It can tax people just for existing."
By the end of the argument Prelogar seemed to have assuaged some of Gorsuch's fears.
"The reason why I would strongly caution the court away from adopting a realization requirement is not only that we think that it is inaccurate, profoundly ahistorical, inconsistent with the text of the Sixteenth Amendment," she said. "It would also wreak havoc on the proper operation of the tax code."
Former Republican House Speaker Paul Ryan, who shepherded the 2017 tax bill through the House made a similar point in September, warning that if the MRT is invalidated, it could unravel a third of the tax code.
veryGood! (425)
Related
- Taylor Swift makes surprise visit to Kansas City children’s hospital
- Fossil Fuel Industries Pumped Millions Into Trump’s Inauguration, Filing Shows
- 6 Ways Trump’s Denial of Science Has Delayed the Response to COVID-19 (and Climate Change)
- Iconic Forests Reaching Climate Tipping Points in American West, Study Finds
- Mets have visions of grandeur, and a dynasty, with Juan Soto as major catalyst
- Her husband died after stay at Montana State Hospital. She wants answers.
- Have you tried to get an abortion since Roe v. Wade was overturned? Share your story
- Suicide and homicide rates among young Americans increased sharply in last several years, CDC reports
- What do we know about the mysterious drones reported flying over New Jersey?
- InsideClimate News Wins SABEW Awards for Business Journalism for Agriculture, Military Series
Ranking
- US wholesale inflation accelerated in November in sign that some price pressures remain elevated
- U.S. lawmakers open probe into PGA Tour-LIV Golf plan
- FDA authorizes the first at-home test for COVID-19 and the flu
- An Oscar for 'The Elephant Whisperers' — a love story about people and pachyderms
- Why members of two of EPA's influential science advisory committees were let go
- Why Lizzo Says She's Not Trying to Escape Fatness in Body Positivity Message
- Your next job interview might be with AI. Here's how to ace it.
- 'Are you a model?': Crickets are so hot right now
Recommendation
Paris Hilton, Nicole Richie return for an 'Encore,' reminisce about 'The Simple Life'
Blac Chyna Debuts Edgy Half-Shaved Head Amid Personal Transformation Journey
Wray publicly comments on the FBI's position on COVID's origins, adding political fire
Rachel Bilson Baffled After Losing a Job Over Her Comments About Sex
Newly elected West Virginia lawmaker arrested and accused of making terroristic threats
Vernon Loeb Joins InsideClimate News as Senior Editor of Investigations, Enterprise and Innovations
Singer Jesse Malin paralyzed from the waist down after suffering rare spinal cord stroke
Heartland Launches Website of Contrarian Climate Science Amid Struggles With Funding and Controversy